X-men (2013) #1 Review

XMEN 2013 #1 (1)

Because you demanded it! The X-Women finally get their own book, from critically acclaimed superstars Brian Wood (X-MEN, ULTIMATE X-MEN, DMZ, The Massive) and Olivier Coipel (AVX, HOUSE OF M, THOR)! An old enemy shows up at the X-Men’s door, seeking asylum from an ancient evil come back to earth. Meanwhile, Jubilee has come home, and she’s brought with her an orphaned baby who might hold the key to the earth’s survival…or its destruction. Against a backdrop of what seems like an alien invasion and an eons-spanning war between brother and sister, Storm steps up and puts together a team to protect the child and stop a new threat that could destroy all life on earth!

 

 The Good

Cover- We have our all female X-men cast with Storm/ Ororo Munroe, Rogue/Anna Marie, Rachel Summers, Psylocke/Elizabeth Braddock, Jubilation Lee and Shadowcat/Katherine “kitty” Pryde all rendered in the same style as the interiors by Olivier Coipel. Everything looks pretty damn good and slick to boot.XMEN 2013 #1 (8)

Villain- So Grant Morisson’s John Sublime makes a return and this time with evil alien sister Arkea. Can’t say I hate the potential here.

School- I found the exchange between Mercury and Bling and how Storm and Rachel dealt with said situation was very well done and clearly shows a dominant side to Storm that has not been shows in a good LONG time. It also made me miss the simpler times of X-men Legacy which once focused on the teachers of the Jean Grey School. Hopefully the human moments like this will get a better shine under the spotlight going forward.

Art- Olivier Coipel’s art is simply beautiful and smooth. His Psylocke and Storm illustrations are strongest though. Coipel’s rendering of Storm’s costume may be the best yet!

XMEN 2013 #1 (6)Action- Rogue totally nailed it this issue reminding me and just about everyone who lived through the 90’s fox animated series why she was so popular. The flight and super strength oh how I miss her with those kree powers. That’s all the action we get this issue but it left me wanting so much more.  

Family- This a powerful recurrent theme in this book as Jubilee feels a connection to this baby because of her own life as an orphan. There is also her connection to the X-men her adopted family. There is an interesting discussion that can be made about biological family and of course those who you choose to surround yourself with.  Also interesting is the dichotomy of Sublime running from his biological family (his sister) and Jubilee running toward her adopted family.

Diversity– In the same breath we always complain about the lack of black superheroes headlining mainstream books, though sales are always lackluster, there has also always been a shortage of other  minorities; Asians, Muslims, Jews, women etc. This re-launch hits quite a few high notes in addressing this problem. Sure it’s a team book but we are getting six women headlining a mainstream book. Two of them are Asian (and no I’m not going to mention that one is a British white chick trapped in an Asian body), one is black and we have three white chicks, one of whom is a redhead (another minority I’ve heard) oh and Kitty is Jewish. Let’s also give marvel credit that this is the second book they’ve launched under the Marvel Now banner with an all female cast, the other being Fearless defenders. DC Comics New 52 should be taking notes but clearly they don’t give that much of a damn.

Black Heroes- Bling showed up at the start of the story and Storm had a pretty strong presence throughout.

 

 

The Bad

Seriously? – So Jubilee knows she’s being followed and after the long superhero career she’s had as an X-man and particularly Wolverine’s sidekick you would think her training or even her brain for crying out loud would have told her that IF she calls the Jean Grey School while being obviously followed said pursuer would need only hit redial on her PUBLIC PAY PHONE. It’s a pretty ridiculous move that ruined the opening set pieces pretty damn badly. On another note she’s now a vampire with the added strength and speed who as trained by Wolverine and THIS was her solution to her problem? (Shakes head) XMEN 2013 #1 (3)

Weird– Ok now someone please explain to me how Storm could be on a train in the middle of the day and everyone pretends she’s invisible? This is where Claremont for all his now dinosaur like writing would have spun that into pure gold. Before she was married to T’challa she lead a very public X-men team which made her a celebrity, Claremont nods to this by having her hounded by Paparazzi that was before her Marriage to an African King, her stint as an Avenger and membership in the Fantastic Four. There would be major excitement having her walk through this train but the art shows her and her teammates in colorful garb not even getting so much as a wandering eye in this train. No, No, No that was all wrong on so many levels I don’t even want to get into it. Celebrity on pubic train does not = what happens in this issue.

Again? –Ladies and gentlemen I give you Chris Claremont’s second worst creation ever from his failed “Revolution” X-men line debacle of the millennium, Karima Shapandar also known as the Omega Sentinel. The last time we saw her before this issue she was possessed by the marauders Male and you know what happens this issue? SHE GETS POSSESSED AGAIN! How original of a development is that? I mean they should win an Eisner award for such originality!   

Also under the again category is an X-man carrying around a baby who’s important to their very survival. I know my mind is shallow but didn’t Cable and Hope start out just like that? Messiah War, Messiah Complex etc? I mean you really can’t get more original than that now can we?

Accessibility- Nitpick to be sure but to truly understand the gravity of having Sublime and his sister go war the reader would need to have read and understood the subtleties of Grant Morrison s entire New X-men run and witnessed Sublimes war on the mutant strain of DNA to even begin to comprehend where this story cold possibly go.

It would have also been a good idea to have a small text box to explain the powers of our team the first time they get panel time. This would have helped new readers keep up with the powers and the power play dynamics present in the school scenario. Storm is headmistress and Rachel was senior staff. Small touches like that would have really enhanced everything.

 

The Ugly

So we have great art and cover, nice potential villains, all female mixed race cast lovely characterization at the Jean Grey School but we have the recurrent tripe of possession by an old character, shoddy characterization of Jubilee, re-current world changing baby and Storm treated like she was Misty Knight. As good as this could have been it really still has a long way to go. 3/5

stars- 3

admin

Caribbean born college lecturer, Multidisciplinary specialist/Androgogue/Philosophical Pedagogue; founder/CEO of World of Black Heroes, freelance writer and all around comic book geek. I enjoy a good book, video games, movies and most of all fatherhood. Written credits include work for Islandstage.net, Comicvine, Independent comics etc.

admin has 2540 posts and counting.See all posts by admin

0 thoughts on “X-men (2013) #1 Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *